Yohanna Katanacho – The Trip from Nazareth to Bethlehem: Theology Faces Politics

yohanna-katanacho
Dr. Yohanna Katanacho

I want to compare between the trip from Nazareth to Bethlehem in the first and twenty first centuries. I am a Palestinian Israeli citizen. I live in Nazareth and continually commute to Bethlehem. In fact, this Christmas I am travelling with my family from Nazareth to Bethlehem. There are several roads that lead to Bethlehem. There are three major options: one in the east, one in the middle of the country, and one in the west next to the Mediterranean Sea. I shall call them: the eastern, central, and middle roads. Which road should I choose? My decision depends on the political situation, my identity, the cost of travel, time, and traffic jams. Jews don’t like to travel through Palestinian towns. Palestinians don’t like to travel through Jewish settlements. In addition, there are checkpoints on the way. These checkpoints are a potential delay depending on Identity, that is, Palestinians or Jewish. If Israeli soldiers at certain checkpoints discover that I am a Palestinian then I am a potential risk in their eyes. It means delay in my trip. In short, travelling is a political decision connected to my identity. As I reach Bethlehem, I usually come through a neighboring town called Beit-Jala. At the entrance of the town, there is a big sign saying: Israeli citizens are not allowed to enter this region by law. However, the checkpoint is not guarded by soldiers or monitored. Entering into Bethlehem is not only a political question it is also a legal question. In addition, it is a theological question. Should I break the law to enter Bethlehem?

This reality shapes my reading of the Christmas story. Politics plays a role in the trip from Nazareth to Bethlehem. It was a political decision that is related to the identity of the holy family that led them to travel to Bethlehem. In the first century the road options were also a political decision. Politicians seem to control our lives as they force us to move from place to another, and as they shape the ways we travel. However, I discover in the Christmas story that God is sovereign over the whole world. The political realities of the world are challenged by the baby born in Bethlehem. Theology enters the world of politics to declare that Jesus is the King. Theology uses a political language to announce that the standards of God are rooted in justice, peace, and mercy. Christmas reminds me that God is interested not only in saving us from hell but is also interested in creating a Kingdom of justice, righteousness, and peace. Its King is the baby Jesus.

How should I respond when theology challenges politics? Should I act like the Magi who refuse to cooperate with Herod’s oppressive politics? They invested their money, time, and lives to empower the new born King. Should I act like the shepherds and believe with joy? Should I act like Mary and Joseph? They chose to become refugees and to suffer in order to support the new born King? It is costly when theology challenges politics. But do we have a choice? If we want to celebrate Jesus then we need to reflect on peace, justice, and love in ways that transform our violent world. Christmas was and still is a time in which massacres happen and pain spreads because of injustices. But it is also a time of hope for unto us a King is born.

Last, what kind of theology is Christmas bringing? While Herod is advocating a theology of hate and violence, the new born King is accompanied with a theology of salvation. It is salvation from sins whether personal or systemic sins. Christmas without Jesus is a curse. The Jesus of Christmas is the savior. Thus it is worth it to make the trip to Bethlehem.

Merry Christmas!

Yohanna Katanacho

 

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s