Vladimir Solovyov on Socialism and Capitalism

The views of Russian author Vladimir Solovyov on socialism and capitalism form the object of a recent article on Acton Institute website.

This may be of interest to you in light of the recent protests in the world, including Romania, against a capitalism without values and compassion.

* * *

In the third book of his work The Justification of the Good, Solovyov focuses on the dignity and infinite, moral potential of every human being, realized in human society. He believed that all social action ought to be limited by morality. Thus, he favored limitations to government power, writing, “[T]he demands of the positive law [of the state] are not absolute but are limited by the natural law which is sanctified by religion….”

In the realm of economics, this leads him to biting criticism of amoral laissez-faire economics and outright condemnation of socialism. According to Solovyov, “To proclaim laissez faire, laissez passer [apart from morality] is to say to society ‘die and decompose.'” The free market, to Solovyov, has no value divorced from morality. With regards to socialism, he writes,

Socialism envies [the rich] and Christianity pities them—pities them because of the obstacles which connection with Mammon puts in the way of moral perfection: it is hard for the rich to enter the kingdom of heaven. But socialism takes that kingdom itself… to consist in nothing other than wealth, provided it is differently distributed. That which for Christianity is an obstacle, for socialism is an end; if this is not an antithesis, I do not know what else to call by that name.

One might wonder, with all his criticisms, what Solovyov’s political and economic views really were. One commentator has claimed that Solovyov was “an early advocate of… the democratic welfare state” due to Solovyov’s view of the state as “collectively organized compassion.” However, one must not forget that Solovyov would emphasize its moral limits. Indeed, he writes,

[E]veryone should have the means of existence (e.g. clothes and a warm and airy dwelling) and sufficient physical rest secured to him, and… he should also be able to enjoy leisure for the sake of his spiritual development. This and this alone is absolutely essential…; anything above this is from the evil one.

It is clear how far he intends the “collectively organized compassion” of the state to reach. In this he is no more a proponent of the welfare state than Pope Leo XIII in Rerum Novarum. Indeed, after establishing that the state can be a means of morally limiting the market (e.g., by liberating Russia’s serfs), Solovyov cautions, “Reference to this fact does not prejudice the question to the extent to which such regulation may be desirable in the future….” Thus, one ought only cautiously to presume that he would have been for or against any particular, contemporary social program. No doubt, we can be certain that Solovyov’s position would be limited by humanity’s moral potential and innate and inalienable dignity.

Read HERE the entire article.


Author: DanutM

Anglican theologian. Former Director for Faith and Development Middle East and Eastern Europe Region of World Vision International

One thought on “Vladimir Solovyov on Socialism and Capitalism”

  1. “…….. C’est cela qu’il faut faire comprendre, par exemple à un Soljenitsyne, justement ébloui par les libertés juriduques de l’Occident : il est vrai selon sa formule, que la cupidité n’a pas attendu le capitalisme, mais le capitalisme est le premier systeme qui LA CONSACRE, ou mieux LA SACRE. ” Maurice Clavel
    Cupidité, lacomie, greed.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s